Is PIP Really being abolished?

Our thoughts at SEN Parent Support Group

The final Milburn Review has now been published, and understandably, headlines suggesting that “PIP will be scrapped for under-25s” are causing a huge amount of anxiety among disabled young people and their families.

So, lets try and break this down for you so you can understand what it might actually mean to your young person or you or your family in layman terms.

Your young person’s PIP has not suddenly stopped. The Universal Credit health element has not disappeared today either.

The Milburn Report contains recommendations for reform. Publication of a report does not, by itself, change benefit law.

However, we also don’t think families should simply be told there is “nothing to worry about”. There are significant proposals here, and if the Government chooses to take them forward, they could fundamentally change the way disabled young people under 25 are financially supported.

|Here is the report in its full glory with key pages noted below:

From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation – GOV.UK

Page 174: A new benefits system for the under-25s

Page 181: A new Youth Allowance for most young people

Page 181: New more flexible help for young disabled people

Page 182: Additional Cost Allowance: a new national entitlement

Page 183: Severe and Complex Needs Insurance

Page 185: Transitioning to the new system

What is Milburn actually proposing?

Before we look at the proposal lets get an oversight of the current scale of DLA because organically those YP transitioning to PIP will be affected also. The report states:

More than 900,000 children currently receive Child DLA

  • Around 77% of Child DLA claimants move onto PIP by age 17
  • The proposal is to extend Child DLA from age 16 to age 18
  • Child DLA level payments would continue throughout that two-year transition period, but would end when the young person entered the proposed new adult youth-benefit system.

That 77% figure is particularly significant. It means the report is not discussing a small or marginal group. It is specifically targeting a large established route from Child DLA into PIP.

At the heart of the report is a much bigger idea than changing the PIP assessment. It proposes creating an entirely different benefits system for young people under 25, built around education, training, employment and support.

Under the proposals:

  • under-25s would no longer access PIP through the current system
  • the Universal Credit health element would no longer form part of the under 25 system
  • a new Youth Allowance would provide basic financial support
  • a new Additional Cost Allowance would provide disability-related financial support where additional costs are established, significant and ongoing
  • a separate Severe and Complex Needs Insurance is proposed for a much smaller group of young people with the most significant needs
  • employment, education, health and practical support would sit alongside the benefits system
  • young people would have routes into education, training or employment through a proposed opportunity guarantee

It is a proposal to restructure how the state supports young people who are disabled, unwell or outside education and employment. For parents with SEND Children and YP then this is key hence why we have stepped out of our normal remit to review this.

What happens to Universal Credit?

Currently, an eligible single claimant under 25 can receive the standard Universal Credit allowance.

Some disabled young people may also qualify for an additional health related element depending upon their circumstances and assessment.

Under Milburn’s proposed model, that separate health element would disappear from the under 25 system.Instead, there would be a new Youth Allowance, with the basic rate initially aligned with the standard under 25 Universal Credit rate.

A higher rate is proposed for some young people who need to live independently.

That distinction matters. Because the Youth Allowance is not simply the current Universal Credit system with a different name.

It is intended to sit within a much wider system designed to move young people towards what the report describes in terms of “learning or earning”.

And what happens to PIP?

This is probably the part worrying families most.

PIP currently exists to recognise the additional costs of disability. Importantly, PIP is not an unemployment benefit.

You can work and receive PIP. Under the Milburn recommendations, young people under 25 would instead have access to a new Additional Cost Allowance.

The proposed allowance would be targeted towards people whose disability related additional costs are well established, significant and ongoing.

And this is where we start asking questions because the detail matters enormously. We do not yet have a final statutory eligibility test telling us exactly who would qualify and we do not yet know what an individual award would be and we do not yet know whether someone receiving a particular level of PIP now would receive an equivalent amount under the new scheme. These will determine whether individual disabled young people are financially protected or lose support.

Our biggest concern: who falls through the middle?

For SEN Parent Support Group, this is where much of our concern lies. There are many young people whose disabilities might not fit neatly into a category of the most “severe and complex” needs, but whose difficulties are nevertheless substantial, long term and disabling.

Think about some of the young people our families support every day.

A young autistic person may be academically able but unable to travel independently, manage unfamiliar environments, communicate safely with unfamiliar people or sustain employment without significant support.

A young person with ADHD may have substantial difficulties with planning, organisation, executive functioning, emotional regulation, safety awareness or managing everyday activities.

A young person experiencing serious mental-health difficulties may be able to work during one period but be completely unable to sustain it during another.

Some young people have multiple overlapping needs.

Others have conditions which fluctuate.

Some mask extraordinarily well.

Some can technically perform a task once but cannot do it reliably, repeatedly or sustainably.

Disability does not always fit neatly into a box marked “can work” or “cannot work”. And that is precisely why we need to scrutinise whatever eligibility criteria eventually emerge.

Being able to work does not mean disability stops costing money

There is another really important principle that risks becoming lost in the debate. PIP is not an out-of-work benefit.

A disabled young person can work full time and still have substantial additional disability related costs.

They may need taxis because public transport is inaccessible to them.

They may need additional support with daily living.

They may require specialist equipment.

They may have increased energy, dietary, communication or disability-related costs.

They may need help to participate in society on anything approaching an equal footing with their non-disabled peers.

Employment does not automatically remove those costs.

In fact, for some disabled people, additional support is precisely what makes employment possible.

So, while we absolutely support genuine opportunities for disabled young people who want to work, those opportunities cannot be based on the assumption that employment somehow removes disability.

What about young people who will never be able to work?

The report does recognise this. It proposes a separate Severe and Complex Needs Insurance for a much smaller group of young people for whom paid employment is not realistically possible.

We welcome recognition that some profoundly disabled young people require stable, long term financial security rather than repeated pressure to demonstrate employability.

But again, the eligibility threshold will be critical. A system cannot protect only those at the very highest end of disability while unintentionally leaving everybody immediately below that threshold financially exposed.

The question isn’t simply:

“Will the most profoundly disabled young people be protected?”

It must also be:

“What happens to everybody else?”

There are parts of the report we should not dismiss

There is a genuine problem when young disabled people are left without appropriate education, employment opportunities, healthcare or meaningful support. Families know that better than anyone.

Young people can spend years fighting for SEND provision and then reach adulthood only to find another fragmented system waiting for them. The idea of properly joined-up employment, education, health and practical support could be positive if it is properly funded, genuinely accessible and tailored around the individual young person.

Creating real apprenticeships, supported employment, education opportunities and employers prepared to make meaningful reasonable adjustments could transform lives. We absolutely want those opportunities.

What we don’t accept is that opportunity and financial security must be mutually exclusive. It should not be necessary to make a disabled young person poorer in order to make employment support better.

The language around “work” also needs care

Perhaps one of the most difficult aspects of this discussion is the underlying assumption that getting a young person off benefits and into employment is necessarily evidence that the system has succeeded.

For many young people, employment will absolutely be the right goal.

For others, education may be the immediate priority.

Some will need considerable preparation and support before either is realistic.

Some will move in and out of employment because their health fluctuates.

Some will require lifelong support.

And some may never be capable of paid employment.

Success must therefore be measured against the individual young person, not simply whether their benefits claim disappears.

Why parents should be watching this carefully

For families with children currently aged 14, 15, 16 or 17, this discussion may feel some distance away.

It isn’t because we all know that transition into adulthood comes remarkably quickly. Families already navigate the move from DLA to PIP, EHCP preparation for adulthood, post 16 and post 19 education, social care, health transition and Universal Credit.

If the Government ultimately adopts these recommendations, the landscape facing today’s teenagers could look considerably different by the time they reach adulthood.

That is why families need to be involved in this conversation before, not after, the rules are written.

But we should not minimise what is being proposed either

There will undoubtedly be people saying that families are unnecessarily worrying because this is “only a report”.

We don’t agree that scrutiny equals scaremongering. The report proposes removing two established routes of health and disability-related support for under 25s and replacing them with a fundamentally different structure.

The report itself acknowledges that some young people could receive less financial support at the beginning of their claim under the proposed model.

That deserves proper scrutiny.

We need to know:

Who qualifies for the Additional Cost Allowance?

How much will it pay?

How will additional disability costs be evidenced?

What happens to existing PIP claimants?

Will there be transitional protection?

What happens to young people with fluctuating conditions?

How will autism, ADHD, learning disability and mental-health needs be properly recognised?

What safeguards will protect young people who cannot realistically sustain employment?

Where will the threshold for Severe and Complex Needs Insurance sit?

And what rights will young people have to challenge an incorrect decision?

Until those questions are answered, nobody can responsibly tell disabled young people that they will definitely be financially better off, worse off, or unaffected.

When would the transition happen?

The report indicates the following broad timetable:

  • 2027/28: initial investment of approximately £500 million to begin building the wider youth support system.
  • 2029: the Youth Opportunity Service would be operating throughout England.
  • From 2029/30: the report expects welfare savings to begin, which indicates the proposed benefit changes beginning to take effect from around this point.
  • New claims: the proposed new system would begin applying to new claims from 2029.
  • Existing claimants: people would move across when they reached their scheduled reassessment, rather than everybody changing on one date.
  • Six months before reassessment: each existing claimant would receive a personalised transition process.
  • During that transition work: existing payments would be maintained.
  • Full migration: the report proposes a maximum rollout period of up to five years

Our view

At SEN Parent Support Group, we support helping young disabled people achieve their ambitions via educational accommodations.

We support better transitions into adulthood.

We support meaningful employment opportunities.

We support apprenticeships, education, supported employment, proper mental health provision and employers becoming genuinely inclusive.

But support into employment must not become a substitute for disability support.

Those are two different things. A young disabled person should not have to prove that they are incapable of contributing to society before the state recognises the additional costs of their disability. And equally, being capable of some form of work should never be treated as evidence that somebody no longer experiences substantial disability.

That is the line we will be watching very carefully as these proposals develop.

The Milburn Report has started a very important conversation.

It has not changed PIP today.

The real unanswered question is not simply whether there will be three new forms of support. It is how much each will pay, how narrowly eligibility will be drawn, and what protection will be provided for young people who have substantial disability costs but do not meet the proposed “severe and complex” threshold.

But if these recommendations progress into Government policy and eventually legislation, they could represent one of the biggest changes to financial support for disabled young adults in years.

So our message to families is simple:

Don’t panic. Don’t cancel anything. Don’t believe every headline. But absolutely pay attention.

We will continue following the proposals, checking what is actually Government policy rather than speculation, and breaking the changes down into plain English as more detail emerges.

SEN Parent Support Group ~ Navigating the SEND Educational Processes for Better Outcomes – Together!™

If you have a SEND Child or YP still in Education then join our private Facebook Group here

Read other blogs that may be of interest below:

For over 450 + Letters, templates, visual guides, timelines and statutory law visit our resource hub here

To subscribe to our resource and platform tools click here

Check Out Our Social Channels

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Need Support With SEN?

Book Your Mentor Support Call Today to kickstart your journey navigating through SEN.

Category

Latest posts

  • All Posts
  • Advocacy & Support
  • Attendance
  • CAMHS
  • CPD Training
  • Draft Review
  • Dyslexia
  • early help
  • EHCP
  • Emotional Wellbeing
  • Funding
  • IEP
  • MENTAL HEALTH
  • Mentor Support
  • Navigating Challenges
  • News Letter
  • Parenting Perspectives
  • Post 16
  • Sanctions
  • Sen Parent
  • SEND
  • Send Law
  • Tribunal
  • Uncategorised
    •   Back
    • APDR
    •   Back
    • Children Wellbeing & Schools Bill
    •   Back
    • EOTAS
    •   Back
    • PDA
    •   Back
    • PIP

Contact Info

Have questions or need support? Contact us today—we’re here to help you on your SEND journey.

Edit Template

Find the Right Professional Support Today

Explore our directory of trusted SEN professionals to find the support your child needs. From Educational Psychologists to Speech and Language Therapists, start your search now and connect with experts ready to help.

SEN Parent Support Group supports parents and carers navigating the SEND journey with resources, advice, and a welcoming community.

Check Out Our Socials

© 2020–2025 SEN Parent Support Group™. All Rights Reserved.
No part of this website or its downloadable content may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form without prior written permission.
This site is governed by the laws of England and Wales.

Designed & Developed By Sprout Hub